Oslo University Hospital

Spontaneous activity in pain patient stem cell-derived sensory neurons arises from one functional subclass.

Spontaneous activity of peripheral sensory nerve fibers is one of the main drivers of neuropathic pain. It can be assessed in microneurography recordings of patients' C fibers and in patch-clamp recordings of dissociated dorsal root ganglia from humans and rodents. In microneurography of human C fibers, a distinct subgroup of neurons, the so-called mechano-insensitive (CMi) or sleeping nociceptors, shows spontaneous activity during neuropathic pain. It was shown before that sensory neurons from patient-derived induced pluripotent stem cells (iSNs) can be used to model this increased spontaneous activity in vitro, suggesting that a disease relevant cell type is generated with this approach. The origin of the spontaneous activity in human C fibers is not fully understood. Derived sensory neurons offer the unique possibility to study patient-derived, single-cell function, allowing for identification of potential mechanisms underlying spontaneous C-fiber activity. Here, we identify 4 distinct functional subtypes of iSNs from healthy donors and a patient suffering from the neuropathic pain syndrome inherited erythromelalgia using patch-clamp recordings. Similar to microneurography recordings from the same patient, spontaneous activity is restricted to 1 functional subgroup that shows tonic firing behavior and seems to be especially prone to develop neuronal hyperexcitability. We demonstrate that spontaneous activity correlates with a reduced voltage threshold of action potential generation and increased spontaneous depolarizing fluctuations of the membrane potential. Our findings reveal that only the tonically firing functional subclass of iSNs shows spontaneous activity and suggest that these neurons may be related to the pathologically active CMi fibers identified during microneurography recordings in patients with pain.

Genetic Variants in the SCN9A Gene are Detected in a Minority of Erythromelalgia Patients.

Gain-of-function variants in the voltage-gated sodium channel Nav1.7, encoded by the SCN9A gene, have previously been identified in patients with erythromelalgia, a clinical diagnosis defined by intermittent attacks of painful, hot, swollen, and red skin, predominantly involving the hands and feet. Symptoms are induced or aggravated by warming and relieved by cooling. In primary erythromelalgia there is no known underlying disease. This study investigated the frequency of SCN9A variants in a cohort of primary erythromelalgia patients collected at a single centre, and examined the clinical signs and symptoms associated with identified variants. One hundred patients with possible erythromelalgia were collected prospectively and evaluated by clinical examination. Thirty-five patients fulfilling the clinical criteria of primary erythromelalgia were screened for variants in SCN9A. Five were found to carry likely causal variants, including a variant found in 2 related individuals and a variant not previously described in patients with erythromelalgia. The clinical findings differed significantly between the patients. Overall, in this cohort only 4/34 (11.7%) of unrelated patients had erythromelalgia likely caused by gain-of-function variants in SCN9A. Variants in SCN9A are therefore likely to cause or contribute to primary erythromelalgia in only a small proportion of patients.

Pain thresholds, supra-threshold pain and lidocaine sensitivity in patients with erythromelalgia, including the I848Tmutation in Na 1.7.

Nociceptive thresholds and supra-threshold pain ratings as well as their reduction upon local injection with lidocaine were compared between healthy subjects and patients with erythromelalgia (EM). Lidocaine (0.25, 0.50, 1.0 or 10 mg/mL) or placebo (saline) was injected intradermally in non-painful areas of the lower arm, in a randomized, double-blind manner, to test the effect on dynamic and static mechanical sensitivity, mechanical pain sensitivity, thermal thresholds and supra-threshold heat pain sensitivity. Heat pain thresholds and pain ratings to supra-threshold heat stimulation did not differ between EM-patients (n = 27) and controls (n = 25), neither did the dose-response curves for lidocaine. Only the subgroup of EM-patients with mutations in sodium channel subunits Na 1.7, 1.8 or 1.9 (n = 8) had increased lidocaine sensitivity for supra-threshold heat stimuli, contrasting lower sensitivity to strong mechanical stimuli. This pattern was particularly clear in the two patients carrying the Na 1.7 I848T mutations in whom lidocaine's hyperalgesic effect on mechanical pain sensitivity contrasted more effective heat analgesia. Heat pain thresholds are not sensitized in EM patients, even in those with gain-of-function mutations in Na 1.7. Differential lidocaine sensitivity was overt only for noxious stimuli in the supra-threshold range suggesting that sensitized supra-threshold encoding is important for the clinical pain phenotype in EM in addition to lower activation threshold. Intracutaneous lidocaine dose-dependently blocked nociceptive sensations, but we did not identify EM patients with particular high lidocaine sensitivity that could have provided valuable therapeutic guidance. Acute pain thresholds and supra-threshold heat pain in controls and patients with erythromelalgia do not differ and have the same lidocaine sensitivity. Acute heat pain thresholds even in EM patients with the Na 1.7 I848T mutation are normal and only nociceptor sensitivity to intradermal lidocaine is changed. Only in EM patients with mutations in Na 1.7, 1.8 or 1.9 supra-threshold heat and mechanical pain shows differential lidocaine sensitivity as compared to controls.

Pathological nociceptors in two patients with erythromelalgia-like symptoms and rare genetic Nav 1.9 variants.

The sodium channel Nav 1.9 is expressed in peripheral nociceptors and has recently been linked to human pain conditions, but the exact role of Nav 1.9 for human nociceptor excitability is still unclear. C-nociceptors from two patients with late onset of erythromelalgia-like pain, signs of small fiber neuropathy, and rare genetic variants of Nav 1.9 (N1169S, I1293V) were assessed by microneurography. Compared with patients with comparable pain phenotypes (erythromelalgia-like pain without Nav-mutations and painful polyneuropathy), there was a tendency toward more activity-dependent slowing of conduction velocity in mechanoinsensitive C-nociceptors. Hyperexcitability to heating and electrical stimulation were seen in some nociceptors, and other unspecific signs of increased excitability, including spontaneous activity and mechanical sensitization, were also observed. Although the functional roles of these genetic variants are still unknown, the microneurography findings may be compatible with increased C-nociceptor excitability based on increased Nav 1.9 function.

SCN10A Mutation in a Patient with Erythromelalgia Enhances C-Fiber Activity Dependent Slowing.

Gain-of-function mutations in the tetrodotoxin (TTX) sensitive voltage-gated sodium channel (Nav) Nav1.7 have been identified as a key mechanism underlying chronic pain in inherited erythromelalgia. Mutations in TTX resistant channels, such as Nav1.8 or Nav1.9, were recently connected with inherited chronic pain syndromes. Here, we investigated the effects of the p.M650K mutation in Nav1.8 in a 53 year old patient with erythromelalgia by microneurography and patch-clamp techniques. Recordings of the patient's peripheral nerve fibers showed increased activity dependent slowing (ADS) in CMi and less spontaneous firing compared to a control group of erythromelalgia patients without Nav mutations. To evaluate the impact of the p.M650K mutation on neuronal firing and channel gating, we performed current and voltage-clamp recordings on transfected sensory neurons (DRGs) and neuroblastoma cells. The p.M650K mutation shifted steady-state fast inactivation of Nav1.8 to more hyperpolarized potentials and did not significantly alter any other tested gating behaviors. The AP half-width was significantly broader and the stimulated action potential firing rate was reduced for M650K transfected DRGs compared to WT. We discuss the potential link between enhanced steady state fast inactivation, broader action potential width and the potential physiological consequences.

Specific changes in conduction velocity recovery cycles of single nociceptors in a patient with erythromelalgia with the I848T gain-of-function mutation of Nav1.7.

Seven patients diagnosed with erythromelalgia (EM) were investigated by microneurography to record from unmyelinated nerve fibers in the peroneal nerve. Two patients had characterized variants of sodium channel Nav1.7 (I848T, I228M), whereas no mutations of coding regions of Navs were found in 5 patients with EM. Irrespective of Nav1.7 mutations, more than 50% of the silent nociceptors in the patients with EM showed spontaneous activity. In the patient with mutation I848T, all nociceptors, but not sympathetic efferents, displayed enhanced early subnormal conduction in the velocity recovery cycles and the expected late subnormality was reversed to supranormal conduction. The larger hyperpolarizing shift of activation might explain the difference to the I228M mutation. Sympathetic fibers that lack Nav1.8 did not show supranormal conduction in the patient carrying the I848T mutation, confirming in human subjects that the presence of Nav1.8 crucially modulates conduction in cells expressing EM mutant channels. The characteristic pattern of changes in conduction velocity observed in the patient with the I848T gain-of function mutation in Nav1.7 could be explained by axonal depolarization and concomitant inactivation of Nav1.7. If this were true, activity-dependent hyperpolarization would reverse inactivation of Nav1.7 and account for the supranormal CV. This mechanism might explain normal pain thresholds under resting conditions.

Erythromelalgia - A dramatic pain of genetic origin, revealing pain mechanisms with implications for neuropathic pain in general.

Exonic mutations in SCN9A (NaV1.7) are found in a minority of patients with erythromelalgia.

Background and aim "Gain-of-function" mutations in voltage-gated sodium channel NaV1.7 have been linked to erythromelalgia (EM), characterized by painful hot and red hands and feet. We investigated the proportion of patients with EM that carry a mutation in NaV1.7 or in other pain-related genes and studied possible clinical differences. Methods In this study, 48 patients with EM were screened for mutations in a total of 29 candidate genes, including all sodium channel subunits, transient receptor potential channels (TRPA1, TRPV1, TRPM8), neurotrophic factors (NGF, NGFR, BDNF, GDNF, NTRK1 and WNK1) and other known pain-related genes (CACNG2, KCNS1, COMT, P2RX3, TAC1, TACR1), using a combination of next generation sequencing and classical Sanger sequencing. Results In 7/48 patients protein-modifying mutations of NaV1.7 (P187L, I228M, I848T (n = 4) and N1245S) were identified. Patients with the I848T mutation could be identified clinically based on early onset and severity of the disease. In contrast, there were no clinical characteristics that differentiated the other patients with NaV1.7 mutation from those patients without. We also found more than twenty rare protein-modifying genetic variants in the genes coding for sodium channels (NaV1.8, NaV1.9, NaV1.6, NaV1.5, NaV2.1, SCN1B, SCN3B), transient receptor potential channel (TRPA1, TRPV1), and other pain-related targets (WNK1 and NGFR). Conclusion We conclude that functionally characterized mutations of NaV1.7 (I848T) are present only in a minority of patient with EM. Albeit the majority of patients (27/48) carried rare protein-modifying mutations the vast majority of those will most probably not be causally linked to their disease. Implications The key question remaining to be solved is the possible role of rare variants of NaV1.8, NaV1.9, or beta-subunits in provoking chronic pain conditions or even EM.

Nonspecific capillary proliferation and vasculopathy indicate skin hypoxia in erythromelalgia.

To report on the histopathologic findings of affected skin in consecutively collected biopsy specimens from 49 patients with erythromelalgia (EM). Skin biopsy specimens were obtained from the foot arch and analyzed by light microscopy, immunofluorescence microscopy, and electron microscopy. Oslo University Hospital-Gaustad, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway. Thirty-one patients had primary EM, 17 patients had secondary EM, and 1 patient had erythromelalgic syndrome. Evidence of microvascular abnormalities in skin biopsy specimens. Light microscopy showed evidence of capillary proliferation in 10 of 31 patients with primary EM and in 1 of 17 patients with secondary EM. The biopsy specimen from the patient with erythromelalgic syndrome showed numerous capillary nests with endothelial cell defects and a slight perivascular inflammatory reaction. Among the 17 secondary EM cases, sparse perivascular lymphocyte infiltrations were observed in the biopsy specimens from 2 patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia and 1 patient with diabetes mellitus. Eleven patients also had signs of vasculopathy based on findings of immunodeposits of C3 and fibrin. Six of 30 patients with primary EM showed endothelial abnormalities on electron microscopy. All 3 investigations showed unremarkable biopsy results in 16 cases. Histopathologic analysis is not useful as a routine diagnostic tool in EM because no morphological changes are specific to EM. The capillary proliferation and vasculopathy are assumed to be a consequence of intermittent skin hypoxia (vascular hypothesis of pathogenesis). Whether the proliferation is a consequence of EM or a pathogenic factor in the development of the disease is uncertain.

Microneurographic findings of relevance to pain in patients with erythromelalgia and patients with diabetic neuropathy.

Mechanisms responsible for neuropathic pain are still unclear. By using microneurography we have been able to record from single C-nociceptive and sympathetic fibers in patients and attempted to uncover possible abnormal functional properties of these fibers of relevance for pain. In two previously published studies conducted on patients with erythromelalgia and patients with diabetic neuropathy, some of the major findings were: (1) spontaneous activity in nociceptive fibers, (2) sensitization of mechano-insensitive C-fibers, and (3) an altered distribution of C-afferent nerve fibers with a reversal of the proportion of the two main subtypes of C-nociceptive fibers, indicating a loss of function of polymodal nociceptors. Although some degree of spontaneous activity and sensitization also was found in patients without pain, these mechanisms may still be of importance for the development and maintenance of neuropathic pain. A change in the distribution of C-nociceptive fibers in the skin as shown in the patients with diabetic neuropathy may help to reveal mechanisms responsible for small-fiber dysfunction.

The prostaglandin E1 analog misoprostol reduces symptoms and microvascular arteriovenous shunting in erythromelalgia-a double-blind, crossover, placebo-compared study.

Based on previous experience with parenteral prostanoids, we studied the effect of misoprostol treatment, an orally administered prostaglandin E1 analog, in patients with erythromelalgia. Treatment with placebo was followed by treatment with misoprostol (0.4-0.8 mg per d), both for 6 wk. The patients (n=21) and a study nurse who administered the trial were blinded. The endpoints were change in pain and need for cooling and global assessment of the treatment. Following central body heat provocation, global skin perfusion, capillary morphology, and change in pain were also recorded before and after each treatment period. Results were compared with data from healthy control subjects (n=11) that did not undergo treatment. Clinical safety and tolerability evaluation included physical examinations, clinical laboratory tests, and monitoring of adverse events. All clinical outcome measures were significantly better after treatment with misoprostol (p<0.01) as compared with placebo treatment and after a 3- mo follow-up without treatment. The heat-induced increase in global perfusion after misoprostol treatment was similar to the control group and significantly lower when compared with baseline (p<0.01) and placebo treatment (p<0.05), respectively. This study demonstrates that misoprostol is clinically superior to placebo in patients with erythromelalgia. The results of the perfusion studies may imply that the mechanism of action of the beneficial effect of misoprostol is reduced microvascular arteriovenous shunting in affected skin.

Pain in primary erythromelalgia--a neuropathic component?

Erythromelalgia is a condition characterized by attacks of red, hot, painful extremities with relief of symptoms by cooling and aggravation by warmth. Although the main emphasis has been on pathophysiological mechanisms related to circulatory changes, recent reports have focused on an involvement of efferent small nerve fibers indicating a neuropathic component. Since the symptoms resemble those described in neuropathic pain, we wanted to investigate the possible affection of afferent nerve fibers. Twenty-five patients with primary erythromelalgia were examined by neurological testing, neurography and quantitative sensory testing. Thresholds for heat, cold, heat-pain and cold-pain detection were compared with those of a group of 29 healthy controls. The patients had significantly higher median heat (39.5 (36.1-40.8) and cold (29.3 (27.1-30.8)-detection thresholds at the dorsal aspects of their feet compared to the controls (37.0 (35.4-37.7) and 31.2 (30.3-31.5) respectively). These findings show an impaired small fiber function inside or close to the symptomatic area in this group of erythromelalgia patients. Seven patients had brush-evoked allodynia and fourteen had punctate hyperalgesia inside or close to the symptomatic areas in their feet. When comparing the individual results, there is a tendency to clustering of patients in two separate groups; reduced small fiber input/no hyperalgesia and normal thermal thresholds/hyperalgesia. Our results showing an affection of afferent small nerve fibers together with the nature of the symptoms, suggest that the pain experienced by erythromelalgia patients could have a neuropathic component.

Pathological C-fibres in patients with a chronic painful condition.

Little is known about the contribution of C-afferent fibres to chronic painful conditions in humans. We sought to investigate the role of C-fibres in the pathophysiology of pain and hyperalgesia in erythromelalgia as a model disease for chronic pain. Erythromelalgia is a condition characterized by painful, red and hot extremities, and patients often report tenderness on walking. We made microneurographic recordings from single C-fibres in cutaneous fascicles of the peroneal nerve in patients suffering from this disease. All patients had had a pain attack recently and psychophysical signs of allodynia and punctate hyperalgesia were found. We obtained recordings from a total of 103 C-fibres and found significantly lower conduction velocities and increased activity-dependent slowing of the conduction velocity of afferent C-fibres in the patients compared with healthy controls. Furthermore, several units with biophysical properties of mechano-insensitive fibres were pathological, being spontaneously active or sensitized to mechanical stimuli. Since these fibres also mediate the axon reflex flare, their hyperexcitability might account not only for ongoing pain and tenderness but also for redness and warming in this pain syndrome. The changes in conductive properties found in the C-fibres of these patients could be the first signs of a small-fibre neuropathy. This is the first systematic study of single C-fibres in patients and it shows an active contribution of mechano-insensitive fibres to chronic pain.

Prostacyclin reduces symptoms and sympathetic dysfunction in erythromelalgia in a double-blind randomized pilot study.

Sympathetic dysfunction and skin microvascular arteriovenous shunting with insufficient nutritive perfusion and tissue hypoxia have been reported in patients with erythromelalgia. The objective of this study was to determine whether iloprost, a synthetic prostacyclin analogue--primarily a vasodilator and inhibitor of platelet activation--improves symptoms and sympathetic function in patients with erythromelalgia. Erythromelalgia is a rare condition, but we managed to collect 12 primary cases for a double-blind, randomized, parallel-group pilot trial evaluating the effect of iloprost (n = 8) and placebo (n = 4). The treatment effect was determined by the need for cooling of affected skin and by vasoconstrictor tests following Valsalva's manoeuvre and contralateral cooling. The results show a significant reduction in symptoms (p < 0.05) and sympathetic dysfunction (p < 0.05) in the iloprost group. Further studies with oral prostacyclins or analogues are suggested.

Reduced skin capillary density during attacks of erythromelalgia implies arteriovenous shunting as pathogenetic mechanism.

Erythromelalgia is characterized by burning pain, erythema, and increased temperature in acral skin. The pain is aggravated by warming and relieved by cooling. Increased microvascular arteriovenous shunting in deep dermal plexa has been hypothesized as the pathogenetic mechanism of pain in affected skin, inducing hypoxia during pain attacks. The aim of this study was to quantify skin capillary density in erythromelalgic patients before and after heat provocation, as increased skin temperature should increase the need for nutritive blood supply by the capillaries. Fourteen patients and 10 healthy control subjects were studied using an enhanced technique of computer-assisted analysis of capillary bed morphology and temperature measurements before and after central body heating. The increase in acral skin temperature was significantly higher (p < 0.05) in the eight patients where symptoms were induced after heat provocation, compared to asymptomatic patients and healthy control subjects. The number of visible capillaries in a field of view (1.7 mm2) decreased significantly (p = 0.01) in erythromelalgia patients from 105 (62-137) (median with total range) to 89 (49-118) after warming in areas with numerous arteriovenous anastomoses (nail bed region). In symptomatic patients an even more significant reduction was observed (p = 0.01). The capillary size was also significantly reduced (p < 0.05) from 41.0 (31.5-50.5) (arbitrary units) to 37.3 (33.0-46.0) in symptomatic patients. The change in capillary density in the nail bed area was significantly larger in erythromelalgia patients -17 (-49 to 39) compared to controls 0 (-47 to 13) (p < 0.05), and in symptomatic patients -19 (-49 to -12) compared to asymptomatic patients -8 (-48 to 39) (p < 0.05) and controls (p < 0.01). The reduced skin capillary density after heating is compatible with increased microvascular arteriovenous shunting of blood and a corresponding relative deficit in nutritive perfusion (steal phenomenon) with skin hypoxia, causing the symptoms in erythromelalgia.

Impaired neurogenic control of skin perfusion in erythromelalgia.

Erythromelalgia is a clinical diagnosis characterized by erythema, increased temperature and burning pain in acral skin. The pain is relieved by cooling and aggravated by warming. The symptoms have been hypothesized to be caused by skin hypoxia due to increased arteriovenous shunting. We examined skin microvascular perfusion in response to vasoconstrictory and vasodilatory stimuli, to characterize local and central neurogenic reflexes as well as vascular smooth muscle and vascular endothelial function, using laser Doppler perfusion measurements in 14 patients with primary erythromelalgia and healthy control persons. Skin perfusion preceding provocative stimuli was significantly reduced in patients with erythromelalgia (p < 0.01). The laser Doppler flowmetry signal after sympathetic stimulation of reflexes mediated through the central nervous system, was significantly diminished in patients with erythromelalgia as compared with healthy controls (Valsalva's maneuver p < 0.01; contralateral cooling test p < 0.05). Local neurogenic vasoconstrictor (venous cuff occlusion and dependency of the extremity) and vasodilator reflexes (local heating of the skin), as well as tests for vascular smooth muscle and vascular endothelial function (postocclusive hyperemic response) were maintained. These results indicate that postganglionic sympathetic dysfunction and denervation hypersensitivity may play a pathogenetic role in primary erythromelalgia, whereas local neurogenic as well as endothelial function is unaffected.

Microvascular arteriovenous shunting is a probable pathogenetic mechanism in erythromelalgia.

Erythromelalgia is a condition consisting of red, warm, and burning painful extremities. Symptoms are relieved by cold and aggravated by heat. A wide variety of etiologic conditions can cause erythromelalgia, but one common pathogenetic mechanism, microvascular arteriovenous shunting, has been hypothesized. The aim of this study was to test this hypothesis. Quantification of skin microvascular perfusion using laser Doppler perfusion imaging and skin temperature at rest and after central body heating was performed in 14 patients with erythromelalgia and 11 controls. Attacks of erythromelalgia were induced in eight patients after heat provocation. In the plantar region of the foot, the location of numerous anatomical arteriovenous shunts, these patients significantly increased the skin perfusion as compared with asymptomatic patients with erythromelalgia and controls. In the dorsal region with few arteriovenous shunts no significant differences between the groups were demonstrated. The results show a relation between clinical symptoms and increased perfusion in the region of numerous anatomical arteriovenous shunts, and support the hypothesis of increased thermoregulatory arteriovenous shunt flow during attacks in primary erythromelalgia.